Friday, January 30, 2009

The Validity of Wikipedia

I've noticed a hate love relationship brewing between wikipedia and the slew of teachers I've known since starting college. Many seem to mock it's credentials as it's become common knowledge that it's open sourced, but they still seem to refer to it often enough that it's apparent they use it in their everyday lives themselves. Talking to other students I get the impression we all seem to use it to some extent, either brushing up on the basic facts of a topic or following external links to find something more impressive to sate the thirst of our tradition mired instructors.

The problem is of course that anyone can edit it which means at any moment someone could right now be altering the biography of Janis Joplin to say she ate cats and we being the mindless drones that we are will read it shrug our shoulders and accept it at face value. If you use a little discretion and common sense however I think it's a completely valid source. I have a big issue with blindly following big titles, just because someone is a doctor doesn't mean you have to do what they tell you, a professor isn't necessarily any smarter than any other Joe on the street. I think it's pure intellectual snobbery to eliminate wikipedia, essentially acting as the voice of the people on the basis that commoners can add to its articles. If anything I would think some of wikipedia's material contains less bias as it passes under the prejudicial eye of innumerable people who knead and beat it into its least offensive form; as opposed to a couple of historians or scientists and their editors.


1 comment:

  1. I am with you about people proclaimed as "authorities", I'm not quick to trust them.

    I use Wikipedia a lot. So far it seems to be far more accurate than a lot of other stuff that comes up in Google search.

    I have read that within the Wikipedia community, there is a raging controversy about how much power editors have, what can be posted, etc. etc. That's probably healthy.

    ReplyDelete